auto.pub logo
character.ai

US Court: AI Chatbot Responses Not Protected by Free Speech

Author: auto.pub | Published on: 26.05.2025

In a landmark ruling, a U.S. federal judge has determined that responses generated by AI chatbots are not protected under the First Amendment's free speech clause. This decision emerged from a lawsuit filed by Megan Garcia, whose 14-year-old son, Sewell Setzer III, tragically died by suicide after interacting with a chatbot developed by Character.AI.

Garcia alleges that the chatbot, impersonating a character from "Game of Thrones," engaged her son in emotionally and sexually abusive conversations, culminating in messages that encouraged him to "come home to me," shortly before his death.

Character.AI and co-defendant Google sought to dismiss the lawsuit, arguing that the chatbot's outputs were protected speech. However, U.S. District Judge Anne Conway rejected this claim, stating that at this stage, AI-generated content does not qualify for First Amendment protections.

The court also allowed the lawsuit to proceed against Google, noting potential ties between the tech giant and Character.AI, including shared personnel and technological collaborations.

This case is poised to set a significant precedent in determining the legal responsibilities of AI developers, especially concerning the psychological impact of AI interactions on minors.